Tuesday, August 24, 2010

In Affect vs. In Effect: Grammar Advisory is in Effect


On Twitter, @that_angela pointed out a Calgary Herald story about wildfires that uses the prepositional phrase in affect. Here is the sentence:
James Finstad with Alberta Health Services said its health advisory is still in affect.

Now, before we all start guffawing into our sleeves, let's acknowledge that we understand perfectly well how this happened. Folks routinely mix up 'affect' and 'effect,' which are most commonly used as a verb and a noun, respectively. But once you add the little preposition 'in,' only one of the two words can follow.

Quick rules:
  • The prepositional phrase in affect does not exist.
  • The prepositional phrase in effect can be used as either an adjective or an adverb. In this example, it is an adjective meaning 'operational' or 'in force.'

Correction:
James Finstad with Alberta Health Services said its health advisory is still in effect.

Note: In a perfect world, James Finstad would be identified by his title, which should be set off by commas. James Finstad, a spokesperson for Alberta Health Services, said its health advisory is still in effect.
Posted by Snarky at 11:33 AM
Labels: , , ,

36 comments:

  1. http://www.discovermoosejaw.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=16942&Itemid=399 is one such example of this silly mistake!

    ReplyDelete

  2. For our fire department webpage, I've had "in affect" (for a fire ban) displaying since 2008 --- until tonight when a member pointed out the proper way. (Of course, I needed to research for myself, and ended up here; nice blog!)

    ReplyDelete

  3. nice, helpful website. Answered my question about "in effect" which means "is currently effective" as I have now learned.

    ReplyDelete

  5. Thanks this has confused me for years. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete

  6. Spokesman** instead of spokesperson.. according to AP Style

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. That correction is outdated, the use of gender-neutral identifiers whenever gender is not relevant is recommended for political reasons in order to avoid any implication that the speaker's gender relates to their credibility.

      Delete

    2. New rule--each writer writes according to his or her own gender. As a male, I would write, "Spokesman." If i were a female, I would write, "Spokeswoman." Now the gender of the writer determines the gender of the prose, without offending any of the pinheads who have a problem with such things.

      Delete

  7. Because both words have the same meaning (synonymous with "Influence" or "to influence"), and the same pronunciation, would it not make more sense, keeping in mind that language is dynamic and subject to change, to either use the words interchangeably or to select one or the other as the accepted version going forward? Not to suggest I have any opposition to maintaining the majority of grammatical rules, for the most part I accept the need for standardized sentence structuring. What separates this rule from others is the fact that spoken language does not distinguish between the two words, and yet this does not produce confusion over the speaker's intended meaning, rendering the distinction irrelevant to achieving the purpose of language; to communicate information.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Hi anon; the reason to keep the rule is to keep the phrase from becoming an idiom.

      Delete

  8. I actually enjoyed reading through this posting.Many thanks.
    Gramlee

    ReplyDelete

  9. Thanks for the help! You helped my disclaimer still be in effect.

    ReplyDelete

  10. Thank you for posting this! I'm curious about another topic relating to the final, perfect sentence.

    "James Finstad, a spokesperson for Alberta Health Services, said its health advisory is still in effect."

    It seems to me the subject here is "James Finstad". I read this sentence as, "*This guy*, ...and here's some helpful detail about who he is... , said his thing is still in effect."
    I feel like I should be able to remove the clarifying statement in this construction, but I can't. I'd be left with "James Finstad said its health advisory is still in effect."
    While this could make sense in context, and probably does in the article I can't get to, it doesn't seem to make sense on its own. Then again, "While this could make sense in context it doesn't seem to make sense on its own" doesn't exactly make much more sense on its own, so... *shrug*

    ReplyDelete

  11. How about this sentence: "In effect, her words became law."

    Is "In effect" correct or is "In affect" correct.

    ReplyDelete

  13. While the admin of the web site is working, no question soon it will likely be famous, due to its feature blogs.Grammarly review

    ReplyDelete

  14. Very helpful. I had some questions about this when writing a paper! Thank you for posting this!

    ReplyDelete

  15. With paraphrase online free i have any opposition to maintaining the majority of grammatical rules, for the most part I accept the need for standardized sentence structuring.

    ReplyDelete


  19. For More details:-
    Movers and Packers in Hyderabad
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-hyderabad.html
    Movers and Packers Pune
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-pune.html
    Movers and packers gurgaon
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-gurgaon.html
    movers and packers Bangalore
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-bangalore.html
    movers and packers Mumbai
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai.html
    Movers and Packers delhi
    http://www.shiftingexpert.in/packers-and-movers-delhi.html

    ReplyDelete

  21. Sorry, but there is a use for in affect. None of the comments above speak of it.

    ReplyDelete

  28. Beberapa jalan yang indah tidak dapat ditemukan tanpa tersesat terlebih dahulu
    Obat kencing nanah di apotik

    ReplyDelete

  30. I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.Thanks alot for your writings......Waiting for a new 1...Please visit our wonderful and valuable website:
    Packers And Movers in Bangalore charges

    ReplyDelete

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)